This video explores a hypothetical naval conflict between China and Japan, focusing on the strategic decisions, military assets, and alliances that could shape the outcome. With China seeking control over the Senkaku Islands and broader dominance in the Indo-Pacific, the scenario examines hour-by-hour developments, including surprise attacks, U.S. and South Korean involvement, and the potential for a large-scale war. Will Japan, with its allies, withstand China’s aggression, or will Xi Jinping’s ambitions succeed?
#militarystrategy #militarydevelopments #militaryanalysis
#themilitaryshow
SOURCES:
https://pastebin.com/W93xQRvd
source
Comments
China carriers are not even decent barges much less functional CVs.
I think some of this is stupid because why do you have Partners?Believe me, what's been going on there in that sea?The Philippines South Korea.Everybody would be flies on s***They wouldn't be waiting for a phone call
Biden doesn't even know where he is or what he's doing and should be in a retirement home in the metal care division.
If Japan calls Joey Biden for assistance they might not even get a coherent response
果然这里的人连常识都没有😂，你们甚至连我们的脸都看不到就会灰飞烟灭，你们不妨亲自买票去美国问问那些美国士兵这点我相信你们可以做到😂
And where's the Philippines where F22s, F16s and other US Fighter planes as well as missiles are ever-present?
And you think that Japanese planes will just be sitting and waiting to get hit by missiles in their respective bases? 😩
The US already has a plan in place for every conceivable contingency. It won't need 2 days to respond. 😩
And we have no aircraft carriers stationed there right now they was all pulled out yesterday
Due to logistic constraints, China did not ACTIVELY asserted it's claim for some time. If you have 2 houses, one in X city the other in Y city and you most of the time live in X city returning to Y occasionally. You return to Y after Z claims that your house there belongs to him. Would you tamely let X have it or would you assert your right over it? Would it sound stupid if some people like you claims that I claim ownership of Y because of some DURIAN TREES planted in its compound (which fruits now fetch good prices)?
Bro I just got the notification for the video only to find out it came out six days ago
All Bull Shit
このシナリオ書いている人に言っとくけどさあ、海の戦いで、軍艦は陸を走る戦車じゃないんだよ。用兵が違う。これ書いているのは中国人なんじゃないか。
As far as readyness and strategy US n Japan has a huge advantage, US has a lot of battle experience, thats why Xi is still thinking deep whether to invade Taiwan or Japan… dont 4get that Japan is once a world power.
I see many of the comments are taking direct issue with the video's assumptions, which is understandable. Keep in mind, however, this is a 'What If' scenario, and it's proposing what could be not what 'will' be. Anytime you try to imagine a scenario like this, it is impossible to realistically replicate the 'human factor' or the 'Fog of War'. Anytime real-live breathing, walking, talking human beings are involved – SHIT HAPPENS, no video game or fantasy can replicate it. At least give them credit for trying. Semper Fidelis! CWO4 USMCR [Ret] 17 Feb 1969 – 1 Aug 2004
Pure wishfull thinking….
This scenario is highly implausible.
While China could launch a surprise attack under the cover of its ongoing incursions into Japanese territorial waters. Its unlikely that Japan would be caught completely unaware.
So the predicted inital loses for the JMSDF are overstated. There is also little mention of the role that submarines would play in such a conflict. Even though Japan has very capable submarines and submariners.
In the event of an open conflict the US Navy would not leave its assets in the 7th fleet within striking range of Chinese aircraft or missiles. Those ships would sortie and position themselves somewhere in to the east of Japan.
Chinese capabilities are also wildly overstated here. Their two aircraft carriers Laioning and Shandong have very limited striking power. Their J-15's cant launch with anywhere near full combat loads of fuel and weapons. As such they would really only be useful as combat air patrol to protect PLAN vessels from Japanese strikes.
If they were configured for a strike mission against JMSDF or USN assets they would likely have to launch without air to air missiles for self defense. Or with a small enough weapons load to allow max fuel for a round trip. As China has extremely limited air refueling capaibilty and none that is indigenous to its carriers.
The scenario also seems to exclude or dramatically limit the involvment of the Japanese Air Force. Especially in the first two weeks of the conflict. The JASDF would be involved from the onset. Their pilots are well trained in maritime strike missions as until very recently the JMSDF had no indigenous air combat arm.
Now add a thousand of autonomous manta rays to this equation 😊
Will the United States go to war with China over a dog?
BIG AMERICA LOST
BIG RUSSIA LOSING IN UKRAINE
BIG CHINA DOES NOT.MEAN BETTER
这用词太简单了吧，完全能听懂，可以练听力😂
US and the rest of NATO will respond … fast … even if russia and n korea joins … US alone is enough to defeat all 3 …
无聊
Missing quite a few other countries here too. India and Australia, as part of the Quad agreement, would come to Japans aid as well as every country China has put off side with its South China Sea claim. They all have skin in that game because if Japan loses they lose too
You seem to have overlooked a fact. Japan is too close to China. If the US Seventh Fleet wants to participate in the war, then they must be prepared to become the best coral reef in the Pacific.
While Japan and China are battling each other… Philippines ship slowly crawling on the south… 🤣🤣🤣 Guerilla tactics…
Interesting, but it doesn't seem too realistic. South Korea will be attacked concurrently by North Korea. Moreover, the US forces in Japan will not be so passive. They will be 'at sea' by that time.
This scenario dont count Taiwan's participation.
China if it acts warfreak, is gone!
Right now it is boxed-in by all Japan-US Allies.
战争不会集中在海洋，导弹互射对方的城市为主
U.S. notwithstanding, Japan has other allies in that area too. This 1 v 1 thing is lacking.
If China did that, they would be picking themselves up and off the floor. And wearing their teeth on a chain. I'm just saying. Japan is so capable…Honda can you make a motorcycle? A car? A Lawnmower? How about a jet, how about an F1 car team. Sure, no problem. Ect.ect.ect.
Do not low rate the participation of submarines in this what if scenario. Also, classified undersea drones. China’s economy will be wrecked regardless.
Stupid thinking 😂😂😂
Lots of good points in the video and many more in the comments. The one thing I don't see that I definitely would strongly consider is Japan immediately sinking all empty Chinese flagged oil tankers as soon as the ballon goes up… with an immediate announcement that by all empty oil tanks would start to be sunk at 24 hours, and all tankers heading towards China at 48. All commercial shipping to be targeted at 72. Limits the environmental damage, but makes it clear China's economy is going down hard. My thought is given the way shipping works ALL shipping would be instructed to immediately leave the war zone. I've also read about plans to attack the 3 Gorges Dam. It would be a horrific thing to do but it would devastate so many aspects of China's economy and life.
Biden probably hasn't realised someone talking to him
No one will be sitting around. Taiwan is now one of most militarized place on earth and has defense agreement with Japan. Fighters assembled and help from all directions against those only good on paper. Within a day, Carriers from different countries arrived as they are close by. There is just no chance. Trump once said Beijing will rain fire once war starts if he’s in the office. I don’t think any war will start in Asia and they got their internal problems to deal with.
Biden doesn't know Biden is even alive
US now has only 4 shipyards that can build over 6000 tons warships. And ONE for aircraft carriers. The correspond number for China is 40 and 6.
Forget about US, it can produce nothing except US dollors.😂
What rubbish.
China Learns the Ship It Put a Hole in Is Covered by US Mutual Defense Treaty: wight=rite?
Waste of time on these war games. Reality will be very differen from what you are painting
This really makes China seem competent. The difference is China is not that competent and the US would strike immediately
The US has organized a Proxy War in Europe using Ukrainians as the Cannon Fodders .
Is the US trying to organize a second Proxy War in Asia , using Japanese as the Cannon Fodders this time ?
Absolute crap we’re do you people get this utter nonsense from,lol
What a pile of drivel! Whi ever put this together is clearly clueless and mistakenly thinks military leaders are as clueless as themselves. They are not.
Dont forget allies and Japan missiles duh and Biden isnt in charge now to be real
If China attacked Japan, their exports in the west would plummet. Is that oil worth the effort?…See Russias war in Ukraine for clues.
China before is an Iron Curtain that make them very poor then American, European,Japan and other democratic countries pour investments to China because of cheap labor, China now is very reach rich and want to rule the world, they spent too much for their militaries😢😢😢
Japanese loves mushroom eggs!